Judge Magney
A reader has contacted us with the
following information that allows another
of Gilbert Walker's pseudonyms
to be "Judge Magney"
One note of interest is that every pseudonym of Gil
Walker's is antagonistic.
He cannot get away from it. He cannot create a generous or kind or
giving or even likable personality.
This is very sad to me.
The
following is quoted from the wikkipedia page at:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Judge_Magney
"Judge Magney" is the pseudonym of an attorney who has been commenting
online about politics and the legal aspects of "gray area" aspects of
live music trading and collecting since 1997. The pseudonym's career is
longer than its internet life, as is the attorney's.
Quotes from
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Requests_for_comment/Monicasdude
"Most lately, Monicasdude has
taken to trying to subvert
Wikipedia into being simply
advertising for his personal sites."
SECProto
Wow. This is ...quite true, and definately
not a good thing.
Lulu of
the Lotus-Eaters
- What a
fragrant batch of
hypocrisy. / While he wants to
delete any links to the sites I operate, he does not object to /
www.bobsboots.com, which is a pure commercial site selling memorabilia,
advertising, and promoting commercial bootlegs;...
- (and then proceeds to personal
attacks of the poster)
- Monicasdude
In truth, Gilbert's site is worthless as an academic tool. It's only
function is to list recordings of Bob Dylan that he has found posted
across the Internet. There are many resources that do this in a much
more organized manner. To attempt to categorize bobsboots.com as a
purely commercial site is as ludicrous as Gilbert Walker's seemingly
endless list of online identities. Higher than ninety-nine percent of
the pages found on bobsboots.com is dedicated to the academic study of
bootleg recordings, and in particular, the vinyl album and commercial
silver CD releases of Bob Dylan. There have been decades of anecdotes,
interviews, collectibles, material and study put forth to create this
massive academic library. We do not promote bootlegs any more than
Gilbert Walker does. We merely document them. Even though asked
repeatedly, We have never sold the first advertisement.
Judge Magney was also hostile with many RMD users in
the exact manner as was monica's dude. Here are some examples:
I simply point out that
you hold a double standard, and that by the standards you apply to Moore (and to
most others, it appears, who hold
political opinions that diverge too sharply from your own), you are dishonest. And you whitewash the
material you and Buck (re)posted. It was not merely "partly
false," but deliberately falsified in most important regards.
Moore, in contrast, posted the Pantagraph text verbatim under its
original headline, in the same manner the Pantagraph chose to display
it on its own web archive site.
JM
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.music.dylan/browse_frm/thread/f5bf56aa283b3645/9203c90b2c89f1f9?lnk=gst&q=%22Judge+Magney%22#9203c90b2c89f1f9
Magney <judge_mag...@hotmail.com> wrote:
Oh, stop whining. You deserved it.
JM
A reply to the evil judge: Do YOU have a webpage pal? Where is
it? NOBODY deserves this. Not even Satan himself would have
"deserved" this.
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.music.dylan/browse_frm/thread/b20d7ab204dc0008/205e75f6f1a81f40?lnk=gst&q=%22Judge+Magney%22#205e75f6f1a81f40
It's quite an easy thing to do a complete search of
the Judge throughout RMD, although you'll find him quite the bore.
While he's not usually as antagonistic as the other Gilbert Walker
identities... strangely... any poster who disagrees with Bill,
monicasdude, etc. became a target for the Judge as well.
|